Compliance Over Time Monitorable Paragraphs from the Section: Community Engagement and Public Information

Number of Section's Paragraphs by Compliance Rating per Report Total of 13 paragraphs in this section: CMR - Report of the Federal Monitor

This chart, titled "Compliance Over Time – Monitorable Paragraphs from the Section Community Engagement and Public Information", visualizes the number of paragraphs (out of a total of 13) assigned each compliance rating using recent Federal Monitor Reports (CMRs) as data sources. The horizontal stacked bars represent different compliance categories for each period. The x-axis of the chart represents the number of paragraphs (0–13), and the y-axis lists the reports. All bars are stacked to show the cumulative number of paragraphs rated by compliance level for each report.

The compliance levels on the pie charts are represented by the following colors:

  • Fully Compliant – Dark Blue
  • Substantially Compliant – Medium Blue
  • Partially Compliant – Light Blue
  • Deferred – Gray
  • Not Assessed – Light Gray
  • Not Compliant – Periwinkle

Details for each reporting period:

  • CMR 8 - Eighth Report of the Federal Monitor, June 2023, covering the period from October 2022 through March 2023
    Fully Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Substantially Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Partially Compliant: 5 paragraphs (38%)
    Deferred: 0 paragraphs
    Not Assessed: 0 paragraphs
    Not Compliant: 8 paragraphs (62%)
  • CMR 9 - Ninth Report of the Federal Monitor, December 2023, covering the period from April 2023 through September 2023
    Fully Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Substantially Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Partially Compliant: 6 paragraphs (46%)
    Deferred: 0 paragraphs
    Not Assessed: 4 paragraphs (31%)
    Not Compliant: 3 paragraphs (23%)
  • CMR 10 - Tenth Report of the Federal Monitor, June 2024, covering the period from October 2023 through March 2024
    Fully Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Substantially Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Partially Compliant: 10 paragraphs (77%)
    Deferred: 0 paragraphs
    Not Assessed: 0 paragraphs
    Not Compliant: 3 paragraphs (23%)
  • CMR 11 - Eleventh Report of the Federal Monitor, December 2024, covering the period from April 2024 through September 2024
    Fully Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Substantially Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Partially Compliant: 6 paragraphs (46%)
    Deferred: 0 paragraphs
    Not Assessed: 4 paragraphs (31%)
    Not Compliant: 3 paragraphs (23%)
  • CMR 12 - Twelfth Report of the Federal Monitor, June 2025, covering the period from October 2024 through March 2025
    Fully Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Substantially Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Partially Compliant: 5 paragraphs (38%)
    Deferred: 7 paragraphs (54%)
    Not Assessed: 0 paragraphs
    Not Compliant: 1 paragraph (8%)
  • CMR 13 - Thirteenth Report of the Federal Monitor, December 2025, covering the period from April 2025 through September 2025
    Fully Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Substantially Compliant: 0 paragraphs
    Partially Compliant: 4 paragraphs (31%)
    Deferred: 7 paragraphs (54%)
    Not Assessed: 0 paragraphs
    Not Compliant: 2 paragraphs (15%)

Excerpt From Executive Summary

Section 10: Community Engagement and Public Information

This reporting period is the first time that all paragraphs in this section were assessed under the new methodology introduced at the end of the previous reporting period. Under the Monitor's Office's guidance, PRP resumed development of a structured community engagement plan designed to integrate community and problem-oriented policing principles into its management, policies, recruitment, training, personnel evaluations, and accountability systems.

While the process is ongoing, these sessions have produced meaningful progress. PRP has begun developing its first operational pilot plan, which includes representative police areas across the island: Aguadilla, Arecibo, Humacao, and Guayama. In June 2025, the Community Interaction Committee (CIC) policy received the Superintendent's approval, allowing PRP to advance its internal engagement efforts. In August 2025, PRP submitted its pilot implementation plan for the selected areas. The Monitor's Office reviewed the plan and submitted recommendations in September 2025, paving the way for pilot implementation beginning later that month. The plan is scheduled to run through March 2026 (CMR-14).

However, two key policies remain pending approval by the Superintendent: GO 803 (Community Policing) and GO 805 (Public Information and Open Meetings – Encuentros Comunitarios). Approval of these policies is essential for finalizing PRP's Bureau-wide community engagement plan in collaboration with community stakeholders. The full plan will also include the development of supplemental community engagement plans for each of PRP's 13 area commands. These supplemental plans will align personnel deployment with the Staffing and Resource Allocation Plan, ensuring consistency with community-oriented policing principles.

Progress in this section remains closely tied to finalizing the Bureau-wide engagement plan, approving the pending policies, and implementing related training and electronic systems. PRP also plans to enhance its community policing data systems under Benchmark Analytics during Phase II, scheduled to begin in December 2025. The scope of Benchmark Analytics' community engagement modules is still being defined, but the Monitor's Office views this phase as a valuable opportunity to institutionalize best practices, strengthen partnerships, and promote measurable improvements in community engagement. Early planning and pilot implementation will be key to identifying challenges and building momentum for effective integration.

During this reporting period, the Monitor's Office also re-reviewed several key documents, including GOs 801 (CICs), 803 (Community Policing), 805 (Community Meetings), PPRs 803.2 and 803.5, and the CIC Rules and Regulations Manual. The Monitor's Office attended CIC Central meetings, Community Safety Council (CSC) meetings, and a community open meeting (Encuentro Comunitario) hosted by the Bayamón Area Command.

Additionally, the Monitor's Office and PRP co-hosted a Town Hall Meeting in Salinas (Guayama Area Command), attended by community members, CSC representatives, local officials, non-profit organizations, direct service providers, and CIC members. Participants shared common public safety concerns and emphasized the importance of PRP's active engagement with local communities. Community members also acknowledged PRP's positive contributions through programs such as the Police Athletic League for youth engagement and Vuelta a la Vida, a referral program supporting drug rehabilitation services.

For this reporting period, the Monitor's Office reviewed compliance evidence from PRP's community policing operations in San Juan, Bayamón, Utuado, Guayama, and Fajardo. Interviews were conducted with personnel responsible for community engagement, alliance development, outreach, and problem-solving, as well as with community members and CSC representatives. While PRP continues to make progress, the Monitor's Office found that some longstanding implementation challenges remain unresolved, and corrective actions have yet to be fully documented.

In conclusion, the Monitor's Office remains optimistic about PRP's progress as it begins implementing the pilot phase of its community engagement plan. Continued success will depend on PRP's ability to establish a structured and sustainable management system that supports long-term improvement and embeds community policing principles into daily operations across all levels of the Bureau.

Overall, the Commonwealth's compliance with the 13 Community Engagement and Public Information paragraphs assessed during this reporting period reflect similar levels of compliance noted during previous reporting periods. In CMR-12, 38% (5 paragraphs) were found to be partially compliant and 8% (1 paragraph) was found to be not compliant in comparison to the current reporting period where 31% of paragraphs (4 paragraphs) were found to be partially compliant and 15% of paragraphs (2 paragraphs) were found to be not compliant.

Source

This executive summary provides an overview of the Monitor’s Office’s compliance assessment for this section of the Agreement and is an excerpt from Executive Summary for the Thirteenth Report of the Federal Monitor, December 2025, covering the period from April 2025 through September 2025 (CMR 13). For more information on the compliance assessment, please see the full report.

Most Recent Compliance Rating by Paragraph Section 10: Community Engagement and Public Information

Filter by Compliance Level
Paragraph 205 Text of the Paragraph 205:
PRPD shall create robust community relationships and engage constructively with the community to ensure collaborative problem-solving, ethical and bias-free policing, and more effective crime prevention. PRPD shall integrate community and problem oriented policing principles into its management, policies and procedures, recruitment, training, personnel evaluations, tactics, deployment of resources, and systems of accountability. PRPD shall engage the public in the reform process through the dissemination of public information on a regular basis.
Current Rating:
Deferred

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 206 Text of the Paragraph 206:
PRPD shall reassess its staffing allocation and personnel deployment to ensure that they support community policing and problem-solving goals. PRPD shall employ a Scanning, Analysis, Response, and Assessment (“SARA”) model to structure its problem-solving approach.
Current Rating:
Deferred

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 207 Text of the Paragraph 207:
PRPD shall continue to conduct outreach to a broad cross-section of the community stakeholders to establish extensive problem-solving partnerships and develop cooperative strategies that build mutual respect and trusting relationships.
Current Rating:
Deferred

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 208 Text of the Paragraph 208:
PRPD shall develop and implement mechanisms to measure its community partnerships and problem-solving strategies and assess their effectiveness. PRPD shall prepare a publicly available report on at least an annual basis that details its community partnerships, meetings, and problem-solving activities, including specific problems addressed and steps taken by PRPD and the community toward their resolution. The report shall identify obstacles faced and recommendations for future improvement.
Current Rating:
Deferred

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 209 Text of the Paragraph 209:
PRPD shall continue to maintain Community Interaction Councils (“CICs”) jointly with community representatives to facilitate regular communication and cooperation between PRPD and community leaders at the local level. CICs shall meet, at a minimum, every three months.
Current Rating:
Partially Compliant

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 210 Text of the Paragraph 210:
In conjunction with community representatives, PRPD shall develop a mechanism to select the members of the CICs, which shall include a representative cross section of community members and PRPD officers.
Current Rating:
Partially Compliant

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 211 Text of the Paragraph 211:
PRPD shall allocate sufficient resources and authority to ensure that CICs possess the means, staffing, access, training, and mandate necessary to fulfill their mission and the requirements of this Agreement. The operating budget shall be revisited on an annual basis in consultation with the CICs.
Current Rating:
Partially Compliant

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 212 Text of the Paragraph 212:
PRPD shall work closely with CICs to develop a comprehensive community policing approach that collaboratively identifies and implements strategies to address crime and safety issues. In order to foster this collaboration, PRPD shall share appropriate information and documents with CICs, provided adequate safeguards are taken not to disclose confidential or otherwise law enforcement sensitive information. PRPD shall seek CIC assistance, counsel, recommendations, or participation in areas including: a) reviewing and assessing the propriety and effectiveness of law enforcement priorities and related community policing strategies, materials, and training; b) reviewing and assessing the propriety and effectiveness of PRPD policies on matters such as discriminatory policing, search and seizure, use of force, the civilian complaint process, and victim services; c) reviewing and assessing concerns or recommendations about specific PRPD policing tactics and initiatives; d) providing information to the community and conveying feedback from the community to PRPD; e) advising the Superintendent on recruiting a qualified, diverse workforce, and f) advising the Superintendent on ways to provide data and information, including information about PRPD’s compliance with this Agreement, to the public in a transparent and public-friendly format, to the greatest extent allowable by law.
Current Rating:
Not Compliant

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 213 Text of the Paragraph 213:
CICs shall memorialize their recommendations in an annual public report that shall be available in PRPD facilities and on the official web pages of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and the PRPD. The report shall include appropriate safeguards not to disclose confidential or otherwise law enforcement sensitive information and to protect sensitive personal or private information.
Current Rating:
Not Compliant

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 214 Text of the Paragraph 214:
PRPD shall develop a Community Outreach and Public Information program in each of the former thirteen police regions or in other operational subdivisions with comparable geographic coverage.
Current Rating:
Deferred

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 215 Text of the Paragraph 215:
The Community Outreach and Public Information program shall require at least bi-annual open meetings for the first two years of this Agreement. During the meetings, PRPD officers from the police region and/or the Reform Unit shall inform the public about the requirements of this Agreement, PRPD’s progress meeting these requirements, and address areas of community concern. At least one week before such meetings, PRPD shall widely publicize the meetings using print media, the Internet, and public service announcements on television or radio.
Current Rating:
Deferred

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 216 Text of the Paragraph 216:
The Community Outreach and Public Information meetings shall, with appropriate safeguards to protect sensitive information, include summaries of all audits and reports completed pursuant to this Agreement and any policy changes made and other significant action taken as a result of this Agreement. The meetings shall also include public education on an individual’s right to decline consent to voluntary searches, consistent with Paragraph 77 of this Agreement.
Current Rating:
Deferred

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

Paragraph 217 Text of the Paragraph 217:
PRPD shall maintain and publicly disseminate accurate and updated crime statistics, including those related to hate crimes, on a monthly basis.
Current Rating:
Partially Compliant

Rating Source:

Assessment as of: CMR 13, Dec 2025

Reporting period: Apr 2025 – Sep 2025

-0-

No paragraphs in this section match the selected compliance level.

Methodology and Compliance Levels

In agreement with the approved methodology, the Monitoring Team uses a combination of quantitative and qualitative methods, including site visits, to assess PRPB’s compliance. The Federal Monitor provides an assessment of the compliance status of PRPB’s policies and practices with respect to the paragraphs in the Consent Decree. The compliance rating labels are applied across multiple charts and tables to provide a consistent summary of compliance status and are defined as follows:

Fully Compliant: The PRPB has objectively demonstrated extensive compliance with the cited portion of the Agreement for a period of more than two years.

Substantially Compliant: The PRPB has objectively demonstrated extensive compliance with the cited portion of the Agreement for a period of less than two years.

Partially Compliant: The PRPB has objectively demonstrated a sub-optimal level of compliance with the cited portion of the Agreement.

Deferred: The Monitoring Team has not received sufficient evidence to reach a determination as to compliance status with the cited portion of the Agreement.

Not Assessed: The paragraph was not evaluated during a reporting period. Certain paragraphs are assessed annually following the structured assessment schedule based on the approved methodology.

Not Compliant: The PRPB has not objectively demonstrated compliance with the cited portion of the Agreement.